Blog=日記: web server benchmark : apache lighttpd nodejs warp yesod tomcat jetty

結論

QCon 2012 で Warp+Yesod がいいと言っていたので、ベンチをとってみました。いいっぽいです

サーバーサイドのチューニングはデフォなので、スレッド数位は合わせてベンチマークをとりたいと思って下ります。なんかサーセン

環境

Server

Ubuntu 11.10

Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU 5160 @ 3.00GHz x 2

Memory 2 GiB

Switching Hub

corega Fast SW-8D

Client

Mac OS X 10.7.3

2.53 GHz Intel Core i5

Memory 8 GB 1067 MHz DDR3

計測の仕方

$ ab -n request_count -c 128 -r -g gnuplot_file_name   http://ubuntu.server:port/path   >& result.txt

This is ApacheBench, Version 2.3 <$Revision: 655654 $>
Copyright 1996 Adam Twiss, Zeus Technology Ltd, http://www.zeustech.net/
Licensed to The Apache Software Foundation, http://www.apache.org/

計測したもの

Apache	Lighttpd
Server Software: Apache/2.2.20 Server Hostname: xxx.xxx.xxx.xxx Server Port: 80 Document Path: /index.html Document Length: 85 bytes	Server Software: lighttpd/1.4.30 Server Hostname: xxx.xxx.xxx.xxx Server Port: 8123 Document Path: /index.html Document Length: 85 bytes
Node.js	Warp + Yesod
version: 0.6.15 Server Software: Server Hostname: xxx.xxx.xxx.xxx Server Port: 8124 Document Path: / Document Length: 80 bytes	ghc: 7.0.3 warp: 1.2.0.1 yesod: 1.0.0.2 Server Software: Warp/1.2.0.1 Server Hostname: xxx.xxx.x.160 Server Port: 8123 Document Path: /index Document Length: 99 bytes
Tomcat	Jetty
Server Software: Apache-Coyote/1.1 Server Hostname: xxx.xxx.xxx.xxx Server Port: 8080 Document Path: /sample/index.html Document Length: 85 bytes	Server Software: Jetty(8.1.2.v20120308) Server Hostname: xxx.xxx.xxx.xxx Server Port: 8080 Document Path: /sample/index.html Document Length: 85 bytes

計測結果

wait time 分布図

30000 request

10000 request

wait time について => Between writing request and reading response

Source らしい(何となく怪しい) から一部抜粋

struct data {
#ifdef USE_SSL
    /* XXX insert timings for ssl */
#endif
    int read;                   /* number of bytes read */
    long starttime;             /* start time of connection in seconds since
                                 * Jan. 1, 1970 */
    long waittime;              /* Between writing request and reading response */
    long ctime;                 /* time in ms to connect */
    long time;                  /* time in ms for connection */
};

テスト時間 (sec)

apache, lighttpd はリクエスト数が多いとテストに時間がかかります。


result/apache-time.dat
request  1       2       3       4
  200    0.028   0.035   0.030   0.031
  500    0.081   0.087   0.078   0.069
 1500    0.187   0.172   0.187   0.185
10000   90.143 109.438 107.131 104.303
30000   18.995   3.584  32.986 327.660

result/lighttpd-time.dat
request  1       2       3       4
  200    0.025   0.025   0.027   0.026
  500    0.063   0.069   0.055   0.053
 1500    2.139   0.561   0.168   0.169
10000  50.097   52.646   2.285  34.739
30000 142.147    5.152 165.114 162.209

result/nodejs-time.dat
request  1      2        3       4
  200    0.034  0.039    0.034   0.032
  500    0.097  0.074    0.073   0.072
 1500    0.238  0.235    0.245   0.211
10000    1.560  1.610    5.101   1.505
30000    8.593 24.368   16.838  31.659

result/warp-time.dat
request  1      2        3       4
  200    0.071  0.093    0.074   0.070
  500    0.160  0.309    0.229   0.176
 1500    1.264  1.057    1.326   1.048
10000    3.115 10.991   11.347   5.078
30000   33.264 34.866   33.098  34.690

result/tomcat-time.dat
request  1      2        3       4
  200    0.021  0.024    0.025   0.080
  500    0.052  0.050    0.049   0.043
 1500    0.151  0.167    0.166   0.153
10000    9.062 10.112    6.957   0.965
30000   21.004 12.324   21.602  18.784

result/jetty-time.dat
request  1      2        3       4
  200    0.025  0.025    0.026   0.028
  500    0.087  0.104   14.926   0.059
 1500    1.127 22.815    1.244  14.990
10000   11.779 11.658   11.648  11.617
30000   36.141 36.806   36.773  36.225

Blog=日記

2012年4月25日水曜日

web server benchmark : apache lighttpd nodejs warp yesod tomcat jetty

結論

環境